The Fire Stations of Bunker Hill

After a couple of solid weeks out in Chavez Ravine, let’s get back to Bunker Hill.

And do you know what was on Bunker Hill? Fire Stations!

There were two engine companies on Bunker Hill, and images of neither made the book Bunker Hill, Los Angeles (though there is a passing mention of the Hope Street station on pp. 16-17). So, in the interest of covering all things Bunker Hill, we’re going to take a look at these stations. (I won’t got into the whole history of the LAFD; to learn more about the noble institution, click here, and don’t forget to go to their museums!)

I. Engine Companies No. 3 & 8, 354 South Hill St. (1896-1900)

We begin our consideration of Bunker Hill fire stations on Hill near Fourth Street, specifically, on the east, even-numbered side of Hill Street. You might ask, is across the street still Bunker Hill? I say yes indeed (or at least I made that assertion when I posted about the Hotel Clark).

Engine Company No. 3 was founded in 1887. They had a couple of locations, on Main Street and West Third, before they moved into this structure, at 352-58 South Hill St.:

Robert Brown Young designed some odd buildings, but this one takes the cake. That parapet is really something. And note the classic “horn and helmet” heraldic badges and bas relief of a fireman, surrounded by Sullivanesque ornament.
LAPL (This was also company 8; in 1896 Company 8 moved from its quarters on Third Street into the station house formerly occupied by Company 6 on Ninth near Main, but then moved into the Hill-near-Fourth for a spell, before relocating to 1839 South Hoover. Most images of this building, though, show it as Company 3, when the number on its facade was a three.)

Aloise Reithmuller built the Hill Street station in 1896 for the Los Angeles Fire Department; Robert Brown Young, architect. LAFD leased the facility, and kept it as its headquarters, until 1900, when they could move into their own purpose-built fire station. The Young-designed firehouse then became a commercial structure:

Now the place to go for New York Turkish Baths
It, and its large neighbor-to-the-south the Hotel Brighton (Frederick Rice Dorn, 1895), were demolished for a parking lot in 1956. From a Hylen negative in my collection

II. Engine Company No. 3, 217 South Hill St. (1901-1923)

In late 1901, Engine Company 3 moves across and up the street, to 217 South Hill St.:

The heavy rusticated stonework and round arches evoke the Romanesque, but the vaguely-Palladian window groupings, symmetry, and dentiled string course place this firmly in Renaissance Revival

Frank Dale Hudson designed Engine No. 3, in 1901, at 217 South Hill St.; it is one of his final solo projects before the October 1901 partnership with William Munsell. Hudson’s relationship to Bunker Hill is probably best known through the Hudson & Munsell Elk’s Lodge.

Los Angeles Times, 17 December 1901

Here is an incredible shot from the Homestead Museum:

It shows the Dorn-designed cafeteria that was built in front of the Hotel Lincoln; the Lincoln, behind, was demolished in April 1919. Locke House and the Moore Cliff (turn to page 126 in your copy of Bunker Hill, Los Angeles) across Second, above. Homestead Museum

III. Engine Company No. 3 and Dept. HQ, 217 South Hill St. (1924-1980)

The 1901 structure is razed in the spring of 1923, and in its place rose a mighty Fire Department HQ, dedicated July 30, 1924:

With its rusticated stonework around massive arched entries, double string course, quoins, and ornate cornice, it made every firefighter feel like he was a 16th-century Florentine banker and art patron

The four-story structure is by Rudolph Meier. Meier worked primarily on large commercial and institutional structures, like the Lynwood branch of Farmers & Merchants Bank of Compton (at Long Beach & Mulford, it was a victim of the ’33 quake), and First National in La Habra (described in the papers as “Modern Aztec,” it was once at Euclid & La Habra); the California Preparatory Institute for Boys, Covina; and Mother Cabrini’s orphanage in Burbank (which became the Villa Cabrini Academy in 1937). His best residential project was this home (once sited amid twenty acres of orange groves) for Thomas Clay Mayo.

In 1950, the Fire Dept HQ gets an addition to its south:

LAPL

Hoooo boy, it is hard for me to love a shot more. This is from LAPL’s Mildred Harris collection, captured in November 1958. Wonderful Bunker Hill architectural juxtaposition: at left is the Vendome, 231 South Hill St. (Charles H. Brinkhoff for the Barr Realty Company; 1900, demol. 1963). Next door, the 1950 addition, designed by none other than Albert C. Martin & Assoc., and the 1924 Meier HQ, and the small structure adjacent is the Fred Dorn-designed auto park and office/shops that became a county garage, built 1910 in the front yard of the Hotel Lincoln at 207 South Hill St. (read about the Lincoln on p. 127 of Bunker Hill, Los Angeles).  Then in the distance across West Second St., is everybody’s favorite dirt patch, with the brand-new County Courthouse looming o’er, and the skeleton of the Hall of Administration behind.

Another look at the 1950 fire station annex:

The 1950 A. C. Martin-designed Late Moderne fire station annex here vaguely reminds one of the 1954 A. C. Martin-designed Modern Richfield Building annex, does it not?

It’s hard to believe, but these lasted all the way into the early 1980s. Here they are in a couple of William Reagh shots from 1979:

LAPL/LAPL

In 1973, LAFD HQ had relocated into City Hall East. In September 1980 Fire Station No. 3 had moved to a new facility at 108 North Fremont Ave. The Hill Street structures were demolished by the Community Redevelopment Agency in early 1981.

Today:

The area is now site of a Wells Fargo Parking Garage, developed by Macquire Partners and opened in 1983. Like the Angelus Plaza facility that wraps “L”-like around it, it was designed by Dworsky Associates. This garage is currently managed by megaparker ABM.

IV. Engine Company No. 16, 139 North Hope St. (1904-1960)

Engine Company No. 3 down on Hill Street—Bunker Hill’s eastern edge—is all fine and good, but what about a station actually up on the Hill?

Nineteenth-century folks living atop Bunker Hill were served by various fire stations nearby, but nevertheless felt it necessary to have their own. Judge Julius Brousseau, of 238 South Bunker Hill fame, led the charge:

Los Angeles Times, 28 June 1900

The Fire Commission agreed, and, after a few years, 1904 saw the opening of Engine Company No. 16, at 139 North Hope St.:

Are those crescent moons on the windows? Someone explain that to me.

It was originally supposed to be Engine Company No. 13, but the firemen figured they had enough problems without adding a “hoodoo number” to the mix.

This station was designed by none other than John C. Austin. Austin’s best-known Bunker Hill building is of course the Fremont Hotel, and he had his hand in a couple of structures down on the Hill’s eastern Hill Street flank, which I discuss here.

Los Angeles Times, 17 January 1904
Quoining! Rusticated stonework! Doric columns! Bilateral symmetry! It’s fun to fight fires when you live in a Renaissance palazzo.

In early 1912, when LAFD added Truck Company No. 6, the station had this 15 x 76′ addition built on to its south side. It was designed by Dennis & Farwell. Obviously, there wasn’t that much for D&F to do, given as their mission was to match the original structure:

Yes, I am aware that in the book Bunker Hill, Los Angeles, I state the 1904 structure (at right) was designed by Dennis & Farwell. That is incorrect, as it was designed by Austin, and then D&F did the addition eight years later. Consider this the corrigendum; it is a mistake to be corrected in the next edition of the book.

An incredible color image from 1960. Note the original building has had its parapet removed, standard stuff after the Parapet Ordinance of 1949. Also, the addition just reads “TRUCK,” since Truck 6 transferred to Engine 4 in 1917. LAPL

Where was this structure, you ask? Well, when you see shots—as you invariably do—taken from atop City Hall’s 27th-floor observation deck, looking west over Bunker Hill:

Let your eye travel up Court Street (near the right in the above image) and then, there, up there near the corner of Court and Hope—

The demolition permit, dated February 7 1961, lists the owner as the Department of Water and Power. As such:

So the next time you’re walking on Hope between the Music Center and DWP, take a moment to think about our long-lost A. C. Martin-designed fire station. (FYI, Station 16 is now in this 1962 structure at 2011 North Eastern.)

V. More Fire-Themed Snaps of Bunker Hill

The vast majority of the images in this post are from LAFire.com — if you click that link and hit the sidebar, the two Bunker Hill-related stations are “Fire Station 3” and “Fire Station 16.” I would heartily recommend you taking a look, though, at all the fire stations. So many incredible early LA structures (with a majority replaced by quintessential postwar structures, and in both cases, a whole host of interesting architects involved—fun fact: Station No. 9 was designed by Robert Brown Young, with requisite Youngian corner tower, though Young designed No. 11 in Mission Revival!).

There are lots of neat shots of equipment-in-action on the LAFire site, so, let’s look at a handful of other images shot by and of LAFD as they ran about the Hill.

Looking south on Hill Street. The area at right, with Locke House and a bit of the Albert Stephens mansion, would be dug out to form the fabled dirt patch of Second and Hill. In the distance, the ornate Victorian towers of the Lincoln (Costerisan & Forsyth, 1888); the 1901 LAFD No. 3 is to its left.
Looking south on Hill Street. Left to right, 235 South Hill; the Hotel Vendome, 231 South Hill; 229 South Hill; and 225 South Hill. The structures at right would later be the site of the 1950 station annex.
Outiside Station 16, looking north on Hope Street. The large building at the corner is the Court Apartments, at the NE corner of Court and Hope.
The Court Apartments (Theodore Eisen, 1906). LAPL. This particular image in the Huntington’s Theodore Hall Collection bugged the hell out of me for years, until I finally figured out that it was the Court Apartments.
Looking west on Fifth, across Hill St. A bit of the Bath Block at left. Center, in the distance, the Normal School (now site of Central Library). Behind the firemen, note Temple Baptist under construction, and the California Club. At right, the structure with the conical tower and bay windows is the Spinks Block, AKA the Broxburn Hotel (Robert Brown Young, 1888).
Center, that’s 137 North Hope St., and at left, is 127 North Hope. Note the lady in 137 who’s wondering what’s going on. Early images of this part of the world are pretty rare. Here’s a shot of those two houses about 1955.
127 N Hope at right; center is 121-123 (seen here in 1955).
Looking directly out the station bay at 134-36 North Hope St.
Shot standing in the street across from the station—134-36 North Hope St., with the back of 141 North Bunker Hill Ave., center. And here’s that house boarded up, in anticipation of demolition.
Lastly, this one’s not exactly Bunker Hill, but it’s pretty close, and it’s too great not to share. Looking south on Olive, from near Fifth, toward Sixth. The two matching structures in the foreground are 513-517 South Olive. The conical tower juts from the roof of the Hamilton Apts., 521 South Olive. The tower behind that tower belongs to St. Pauls Episcopal (Burgess J. Reeve, 1882). This is all the site, now, of the Biltmore Hotel.

And now you know more than you ever thought you’d know about Engine Companies Three and Sixteen, and their once-upon-a-time locations on Bunker Hill. You’re welcome!

One thought on “The Fire Stations of Bunker Hill

Leave a comment