The HOTEL CLARK is OPEN!

I moved to Los Angeles in 1993. I spent most of my time downtown, looking at buildings. I managed to get a job downtown, after which I spent all my time downtown looking at buildings.

The Beaux-Arts buildings, in particular, enthralled me. Their symmetry, hierarchy, and proportion stressed order and control. They expressed an age (whether such an age truly existed, or not) that was elegant, civilized, and morally coherent. Counting columns and cataloging entablatures gave me succor, in the era of Rodney King, Northridge, gang violence, the Rampart scandal, industrial evisceration, capital flight, and so forth. I was hooked.

Too hooked, said some, in that I spent an inordinate amount of time transfixed by these beauties, willingly giving myself over to the paralysis of Stendahl syndrome. A friend studying psychology said I suffered from “compulsive hyperfixation,” or something equally awesome, which only made me dive more pointedly into Beaux-Arts scopophilia.

I gazed, in particular, at the grand abandoned structures. An abandoned structure exists outside the normal rhythms of life, suspended between what it was and what it might still become; its patina becomes a form of authorship. And none thrilled and enthralled like the Hotel Clark, the great grey monument to grinding attrition.

Strictly speaking, she was owned (albeit by indifferent and negligent absentee owners) and was therefore not abandoned, but the old dowager stood nevertheless, for years on end, padlocked and groaning under strata of guano. Ever steadfast, though, her eleven stories of soot-blackened granite held vigil against the encroaching dark. The empress had outlived her empire, but I still pledged fealty to her.

When I moved to L.A. in 1993, the Clark had only been empty for a year or so. She had been purchased in 1988 by May Wah International, a Taiwanese investment group/hotel development company run by the Chinese government (unresolved issues regarding who they were: contemporary accounts say they’re headquartered in Guangdong Province, which would make them PRC, while other sources say they’re Taiwanese, which would make them ROC). May Wah had spent the previous four years battling, and finally evicting, the last few elderly residents. May Wah then sat on the property and let it rot until 1998, when it was sold to New York’s Chetrit Group. At which point we all exclaimed huzzah! The Chetrits will know what to do! The mighty Clark should be up and running in time for the 21st century!

Except, no. “Reopening” notices came and went.

from this 2001 Caltrans report

In December 2011, Brigham Yen announced: “Breaking News: Hotel Clark to be Reborn as King & Grove Hotel in Downtown LA” — and come April 2013, Curbed LA announced the Clark could open “by June“; in 2018, Eater said the Clark could open “this year,” and in 2019 Urbanize said it would open in September, while Commercial Observer claimed it was set to open in November, etc. etc.

Los Angeles Downtown News, February 24, 2015

Somewhere around mid-2023, there was motion and movement at the Clark. Occasional lights on at night. Then, dumpsters stuffed with old furniture shared the curb with trucks full of new mattresses. Still, after thirty-some years of talk, I was ready to believe nothing and trust less.

So for the last three years I’d kept my eyes and ears open for a big Grand Opening announcement, only to discover they’d had a “soft launch” a couple weeks ago in mid-September. I’m running the trains at Angels Flight, and one of my regulars staggers up. “Guess where I just had cocktails!” “Where?” “The CLARK!” “The hell you did.” At that he pulled out his credit card receipt and slapped it down on the counter. There it was. Clark Hotel, 426 South Hill Street.

At that moment the whole world shifted. The gravity I’d spent three decades propped against had been turned off. The lack of the Clark had been my roomate for thirty years. Its arrival demolished the architecture of my life, or at least a supporting beam. In any event, I made my way over, took photos, and began percolating a blog post for this here Bunker Hill blog.

While the Clark may not be, strictly speaking, Bunker Hill, it is certainly part of the local landscape. A decade after Eli Payson Clark built his eponymous hotel, he built Bunker Hill’s Subway Terminal Building across the street (as seen in Marsak’s Guide to Bunker Hill). Bunker Hill faced the Clark and vice versa; here’s the Clark under construction in 1913, shot from the roof of the Zelda at Fourth and Grand:

Rose Mansion, Fourth and Grand, in foreground; red tile towers belong to the Fremont, Fourth and Olive. Note the tall tower rising from the Clark; classic F. O. Engstrum technique — Engstrum was an important pioneer in early skyscraper engineering, largely due to his innovative use of a gravity-chuting pour system to construct reinforced concrete buildings. USC

And, more importantly, the Clark is a fetish of mine, and it’s my blog, and I’ve waited three decades to write this very post, so there you go. To the Clark!

Los Angeles Times, December 24, 1911
Hill Street between Fourth and Fifth. Far left, the A. P. Johnson Block/Hotel Clarendon/Hotel Sherman, 400-412 South Hill St. (Robert Brown Young, 1896); the two-story building at right, the Steinhardt Block/Hotel Leroy, 424 South Hill St. (Robert Brown Young, 1897). Far right, a sliver of the three-story Eliza Wilson Block/Hotel Occidental, 428-44 South Hill Street (Robert Brown Young, 1898). Everything between the Sherman and the Occidental would be demolished for the Clark in April 1912. LAPL
Los Angeles Herald-Examiner, Jan. 21, 1914

Eli P. Clark hired Harrison Albright to design his eponymous hotel. It opens in early 1914.

Some entrance evolution:

1920/1939/1957/1974
The lobby, ca. 1915 and 1935
Upper left, ca. 1955; right, ca. 1965, after closing off the mezzanine; lower left, today
Folks I talked to insisted there was no basement. The Grill Room, though, definitely still down there somewhere. In mid-1945 the Grill Room became the Marine Room, designed by Heitschmidt & Matcham (note the painting of the USS Los Angeles CA-135, the naval lighting, and striped canvas evoking maritime culture), and was remodeled again when it became the Orleans Room (Wayne McAllister, 1953). Marine Room remodel pic: Getty/Shulman

There was also a cozy English tavern off the lobby:

Still trying to puzzle out exactly where this was
In Clark his keep, where weary wights repair, A noble boon awaiteth travelers there!
Oh! to go drinking at the Pacific Room! Bask in the swank California Moderne of Wayne McAllister. This is likely a remodeling of the Ye Tavern but I’m not convinced.
A reverse shot of the Pacific Room
Hotel Clark bedrooms, ca. 1940 and ca. 1965
Part of the Clark: the Occidental Hotel (R. B. Young, 1896) got a neighbor to the north with the construction of the Clark. In late 1936 the Eli P. Clark company demolished the adjacent hotel and hired Walker & Eisen to design this commercial structure.
The Clark, 1946/1957. The finials were removed in late-June 1951, in accordance with L.A.’s 1949 notorious LABC Section 91.8114 ordinance. Despite the loss of the finials, S & L Properties, who at that time owned the Clark, did opt to spend the money to properly brace the parapet, instead of stripping it off altogether, as far too many building owners did. Image at right: CalStateLib
The blazing red neon of the rooftop sign, shot from City Hall in December 1958

May I regale you with some objets d’art from my collection?

I don’t have the affirmative paperwork on the matter, but I assume the vertical blade neon went up around ’37, at the same time Ellis Neon installed the rooftop signage
There need to be a whole lot more “then-n-nows” with the interiors, but, can’t have everything right out of the gate
A cellophane tape dispenser and candle holder
Every room equipped with its own porcelain matchstand/ashtray!
Orange tabby newsboys dream of Santa
Washing up at the Clark
Mail’s in!
A pot of hot water to freshen your morning tea, m’lady
Uh-oh, looks like somebody took off his wedding ring!
Hotel Clark uniform badge
Snagged these pix from eBay listings I lost years ago — I own neither, but boy, wish I did!

Your next question being, what did I see on my journey to the newly-reopened Hotel Clark (which is being managed by OTH Hotels Resorts)? Let’s take a look:

Behold the majesty! The parking entrance at left used to open onto showroom floor and acted as Hill Street entrance to the Broadway Department Store, which fronted on Broadway
The 1930s blade sign undergoing restoration in 2010; restored, now, well, mostly
Of all the ghost signs downtown, this one is the most ghostiest
A capacious lobby. Bars and entrance from parking to the left.
Here’s a room being readied for you. Op-Art carpeting, zebra wallpaper, faux-croc headboard, and some sort of Piero Fornasetti doing Eyes of Laura Mars staring at you. Is it how I would have decorated? I believe all interiors should be designed by Ogden Codman Jr., so, no.
I’ve been waiting a loooong time for this: the view from this side of the iconic HC-logo-emblazoned fire escapes!
A rare treat: up close and personal with the blade sign. Yes, I put it into my 2001 book about Los Angeles neon!
Fifteen years ago, there were large holes in the roof of the Walker & Eisen-designed Clark Annex. No more! What’s in there now? Looks like linen-covered tables…
In fact, the Annex now contains Votana
And Clark Annex pool has the best view there is, but I’ll admit, I’m biased

And that, ladies and gentlemen, is my quick little post about the now-opened Hotel Clark … which somehow managed to contain sixty-some images (but could have contained sixty more). There’s a lot more Clark history to be uncovered, of course.

And, naturally, we’ll keep watchful eyes on another long-delayed Chetrit property, our beloved Trinity Auditorium. One does wonder how the Chetrits pulled off the opening of the Clark, given their current financial straits.

In the meantime, I suggest you check out the Clark yourself — and I’ll see you at Ye Tavern!

One thought on “The HOTEL CLARK is OPEN!”

Leave a Reply